Choosing between the Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon and the Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) is not a like for like decision, it is a workflow decision. One keeps your kitchen tidy while you collect scraps, the other feeds your raised beds directly.
If you want a stainless pail with a lid that lives on the counter, the Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon is built for that daily collection job. If you want a ready to use organic blend to improve moisture retention and structure in your beds, the Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) is the garden ready input you add at planting time.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of our links, The Yardstead may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never influence which products we recommend or how we rank them. Read our Affiliate Disclosure for details.
Quick Picks at a Glance
Prime GranRosi P10 Kitchen Compost Bin 1.3 Gallon
Prime Epica Stainless Steel Kitchen Compost Bin 1.3
Prime Utopia Kitchen Stainless Steel Countertop Compost
Prime Back to the Roots Organic Premium Compost 25.7qt
Prime QYRCXX 4-Pack Inground Worm Composting Bins
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Pros
- Excellent odor control with long lasting charcoal filters that also help reduce gnats
- Attractive farmhouse design that blends beautifully with kitchen decor
- Durable, rust resistant stainless steel that wipes clean easily
- Compact 7.2 inch footprint fits neatly on crowded countertops
- Strong, comfortable handle makes emptying easy and balanced
Cons
- Vented lid is not fully sealed, so fruit flies can get in if scraps sit too long in warm weather
- Filter fits loosely inside the lid and does not create a pest proof seal
- 1.3 gallon size requires frequent emptying for large families or heavy meal prep
The GranRosi P10 is a 1.3-gallon stainless steel compost pail designed for daily kitchen use on the countertop. It is ideal for apartment dwellers, small families, and anyone who wants to collect food scraps without hiding an unsightly bucket under the sink.
Its standout feature is the charcoal filter system built into the lid, which includes three filters for up to a year of odor protection. In everyday use it keeps kitchens smelling fresh and helps limit gnats, while the compact oval size holds several days of peels and coffee grounds before needing to be emptied.
Built from food-safe stainless steel with a protective coating inside and out, the pail resists rust, scratches, and leaks. The vintage inspired white oval silhouette and fitted lid look intentional on the counter, and the reinforced handle stays cool and balanced when carrying scraps to an outdoor bin.
It is not completely airtight, as the vented lid and loose fitting filter can allow small flies to enter if scraps are left for many days in summer. The 1.3-gallon capacity is perfect for small kitchens but will need more frequent emptying for heavy cooks or larger households.
Overall, the GranRosi P10 delivers an attractive, durable, and low maintenance solution for countertop composting. If you want an odor controlled, easy to clean pail that looks good enough to leave out, it is an excellent and practical choice.
Brand: GranRosi, Model: P10, Capacity: 1.3 gallons, Dimensions: 7.2 x 7.2 x 11.5 inches, Weight: 1200g, Shape: Oval
Material: Food-safe stainless steel with rust resistant coating, Color: White, Includes: 3 activated charcoal filters with 3 to 4 months life per filter
Care: Wipe lid with damp cloth, wash body with warm soapy water, no plastic liner required, fitted lid and carry handle for transport
Pros
- Excellent odor control with airtight lid and charcoal filter system
- Compact yet spacious 1.3 gallon capacity fits neatly on countertops
- Durable, rust and leak resistant one-piece stainless steel build
- Easy to clean and maintain with long lasting replaceable filters
- Stylish modern silver finish complements any kitchen decor
Cons
- Hand wash recommended to preserve finish, not ideal for dishwasher heavy routines
- Charcoal filters require gentle rinsing and replacement every 3 to 6 months
- Handle screws may loosen over time and need occasional tightening
The Epica Kitchen Compost Bin is a 1.3 gallon stainless steel countertop bin designed for everyday food scrap collection. It is ideal for apartment dwellers, small families and anyone starting home composting who wants a compact, odor free solution.
In daily use, the airtight lid and replaceable activated charcoal filter work together to contain strong odors from onions, garlic and other scraps. Users consistently report a fresher kitchen even after several days of use, with no smells escaping and no leaks.
Built from premium one-piece molded stainless steel, the bin resists rust, scratches and leaks while maintaining a sleek silver look. At 7.16 inches wide and 11 inches tall, it sits neatly on countertops and adds a modern touch recognized by Bon Appetit and Forbes.
Maintenance is simple but requires regular attention, as the bin is best hand washed with warm water and filters need gentle rinsing and replacement every 3 to 6 months. A few users noted the handle screw can loosen when emptying, so periodic tightening is recommended.
Overall, the Epica Compost Bin delivers durable performance, smart odor control and easy cleaning in a stylish compact form. It is a top choice for anyone seeking a reliable, low hassle countertop composting bin for daily kitchen use.
Capacity: 1.3 Gallons, Dimensions: 7.16" L x 7.16" W x 11" H, Weight: Lightweight, Color: Silver, Shape: Cylindrical
Material: Premium Stainless Steel, Features: One-Piece Molded Design, Rust and Scratch Resistant, Leak Resistant, Airtight Lid
Odor Control: Replaceable Activated Charcoal Filter, lasts 3 to 6 months with proper care, gentle rinse and air dry to extend life
Model Number: SYNCHKG123584, Brand: Epica, Item Type: Indoor Compost Bin, Best For: Countertop Use
Pros
- Excellent odor control with replaceable charcoal filters
- Compact footprint fits neatly on most countertops
- Strong, rust resistant stainless steel construction
- Attractive design that looks good left out in the kitchen
- Easy to empty and clean with simple rinsing
Cons
- Charcoal filters need periodic replacement to stay effective
- Interior can discolor if liner bags leak
- Lid must be kept fully closed to prevent fruit flies
The Utopia Kitchen Countertop Compost Bin is a 1.3 gallon stainless steel pail designed to collect daily food scraps right on your kitchen counter. It is perfect for apartment residents, home cooks and gardeners who want to compost without an outdoor bin or frequent trips outside.
In daily use, the bin holds about a week of peels, coffee grounds and vegetable scraps without overflowing. The charcoal filter in the lid does an impressive job trapping odors, and reviewers note they can go days without any smell even when the bin is full, with easy cleanup using a quick rinse.
Built from sturdy stainless steel, the bin resists scratching, chipping and rust even with constant exposure to moisture and acidic scraps. Its 7.2 inch wide, 11.2 inch high cylindrical shape has a sleek silver finish that looks intentional on the counter rather than like a trash can.
There are a few minor tradeoffs to consider. The charcoal filter needs periodic replacement to stay effective, and if you leave the lid ajar you may attract fruit flies. Leaking liner bags can also leave slight discoloration inside the steel over time.
Overall, this is a practical, attractive and low maintenance solution for everyday composting. If you want a durable, odor controlled bin that blends into your kitchen and simplifies scrap collection, it is an excellent value and a smart buy.
Brand: Utopia Kitchen
Model: CB-13
Capacity: 1.3 Gallon (4.92 Liters)
Material: Stainless Steel
Color: Silver
Shape: Cylindrical
Dimensions: 8.4L x 7W x 11H inches
Weight: 2 Pounds
Features: Lid with replaceable charcoal filter for odor control
Pros
- 100% organic and peat-free sustainable composition
- Excellent moisture retention and even water absorption
- pH balanced to promote stronger roots and bountiful harvests
- Nutrient rich formula optimized for edible plants in raised beds
- Made in the USA with satisfaction guarantee and social impact program
Cons
- 25.7 quart size may require multiple bags for larger raised beds
- Designed as a compost mix and may need blending with existing soil
- Premium organic formulation costs more per volume than bulk compost
Back to the Roots 25.7qt Organic Premium Compost is a peat-free raised bed mix formulated specifically for edible gardens. It is ideal for home gardeners growing herbs, vegetables and fruits who want an organic, sustainable foundation for healthier harvests.
In real world use, the blend delivers noticeably better moisture control and nutrient availability. Yucca extract and gypsum help soil absorb and retain water evenly, while dolomitic limestone keeps pH balanced for vigorous root growth and more flavorful produce.
Build quality reflects a thoughtful, eco conscious design. Instead of imported peat, it uses upcycled wood fines sourced in the United States, creating a rich, airy texture that supports healthy soil biology and long term plant vitality.
The main limitation is coverage, as a single 25.7 quart bag will not fill a large raised bed on its own. It is also designed to be used as a compost mix, so gardeners may need to blend it with existing soil or add supplemental nutrition for heavy feeding crops.
Overall, this is an excellent premium choice for organic raised bed gardening. If you value sustainability, consistent moisture and a nutrient rich start for edibles, this compost mix delivers strong performance with a satisfaction guarantee for peace of mind.
Brand: Back to the Roots
Size: 25.7 Quart (1 Cubic Foot) / 822.4 Ounce
Style: Organic Premium Compost, Peat-Free
Intended Use: Compost Mix for Raised Beds, Herbs, Vegetables and Fruits
Key Ingredients: Upcycled Wood Fines, Yucca Extract, Dolomitic Limestone, Gypsum
Origin: Made in the USA
UPC: 810667035419
Pros
- Durable rust-resistant stainless steel holds up outdoors
- 360-degree ventilation promotes fast decomposition and quickly draws in worms
- Tight sealing lids keep bedding moist and deter pests
- Includes 4 bins in two sizes for versatile garden placement
- Ready to use with no assembly and includes metal lifting hook
Cons
- Small usable capacity requires frequent refilling for larger households
- Thin mesh wires may feel delicate and raised concerns about worm safety
- Lids have very tight tolerance and can be hard to close if soil gets in the rim
The QYRCXX 4-Pack Inground Worm Composting System is designed for gardeners who want to compost directly in raised beds and vegetable patches. It is best suited for beginners and small households looking for a low maintenance alternative to bulky tumblers.
In real world use, the 360-degree ventilated mesh performs well and users report bins full of worms in under two days. Worms enter freely, break down fruit and vegetable scraps, and distribute castings directly into the surrounding soil to improve fertility.
Build quality stands out with rust-resistant stainless steel, smooth edges and an all metal design built for moist outdoor conditions. Each bin comes with a secure snap-on lid and a metal hook for hygienic lid removal, and no assembly is required.
There are some drawbacks to note. The interior capacity is quite small so larger families will fill them quickly and need frequent refills. The lids fit very tightly so dirt in the rim can make closing tricky, and shallow installation may allow critters to dig around the bins.
Overall, this is a practical and durable starter kit for in-ground vermicomposting. If you want an easy, chemical free way to recycle food waste and boost raised bed health, this flexible 4-pack delivers solid value.
Brand: QYRCXX | Model: qyrcxx-w2-4pack | Material: Stainless Steel | Color: White | Shape: Cylindrical
Set includes 2 small bins at 3.6 x 3.6 x 11.8 inches and 2 large bins at 4.3 x 4.3 x 12.2 inches, each with lid and lifting hook
Features 360-degree ventilated mesh, secure snap-on lids, rust-resistant construction and no assembly required
Head-to-Head: How They Compare for Real Use
Purpose and End Use: Collection Tool vs Soil Input
The Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon is a collection tool, not a soil amendment. Its job is to hold peels, coffee grounds, and food scraps for days at a time on your countertop, then let you carry them to an outdoor tumbler, pile, or municipal bin. It does not amend soil on its own.
The Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) is the opposite, it is the soil input itself. This 100% organic and peat free blend is intended for use as a compost mix in raised beds for herbs, vegetables, and fruits. It is made from upcycled plant matter and wood fines, with yucca extract, dolomitic limestone, and gypsum to support moisture control and pH balance.
Material and Build: Stainless Steel Pail vs Bagged Blend
The Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon uses food safe stainless steel with a special coating inside and out that is described as rust resistant and scratch resistant. The fitted lid is designed to stay seated during transport, and the reinforced carry handle stays cool and clean while you move 1.3 gallons of scraps. Owners commonly report it wipes clean with warm soapy water.
The Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) has no hard shell, it is a bagged blend designed to be poured directly into beds. Its build is about composition rather than hardware, with a focus on peat free, USA made ingredients and a nutrient rich mix for raised bed growing. You will not clean it, you will work it into your soil.
Capacity, Footprint and Placement
The Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon holds 1.3 gallons in a compact oval footprint of 7.2 by 7.2 by 11.5 inches. That size is intentionally countertop friendly, large enough for several days of scraps but small enough to leave prep space. It belongs indoors, within arm’s reach while you cook.
The Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) is measured in cubic feet for the garden, not gallons for the kitchen. One bag gives you 25.7 quarts to fill or top off a raised bed, and it lives outdoors in your beds after application. If you are comparing footprints, think counter space versus bed space, they do not compete for the same spot. For outdoor systems, many gardeners pair a countertop pail with a larger compost tumbler dual chamber setup.
Odor Control, Maintenance and What Comes in the Box
The Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon ships with odor control built in, including three activated charcoal filters with one pre installed and two replacements. Each filter is rated to last 3 to 4 months, so the box includes roughly 9 to 12 months of coverage. Maintenance is a weekly rinse of the body and a gentle wipe of the lid, with light rinsing of filters to extend life.
The Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) does not need filters or weekly cleaning, its maintenance is garden care. You get the blend itself, formulated for better moisture control and water absorption, plus the brand’s satisfaction guarantee and Grow One Give One program. There are no replaceable parts, you simply store any unused mix dry until you need it. If odors are your main concern indoors, you may also want to review how an electric compost bin vs compost aerator tool handles odor differently.
Which One Should You Get
Choose Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon if you cook often, want scraps off the cutting board without trips outside, and need a tidy, rust resistant pail that controls odors on the counter. It is ideal for apartment dwellers, small kitchens, or anyone who already has an outdoor pile or tumbler and just needs a reliable indoor shuttle with a comfortable handle and long lasting charcoal filters.
Choose Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) if your immediate goal is to plant or refresh a raised bed and you want a peat free, organic compost mix that improves moisture retention and supports vegetables, herbs, and fruits. It is the better fit when you have beds to fill, need pH balancing support from dolomitic limestone, and prefer upcycled, USA made ingredients over collecting more kitchen hardware.
Another option worth a look if neither of these two is an exact match is the Epica Kitchen Compost Bin for Kicthen Countertops, the Utopia Kitchen Countertop Compost Bin 1.3 Gallon, or the 4PCS Inground Worm Composting Bin Turn Food Waste, which offers an in ground vermicomposting approach for garden beds.
Who Should Skip Both
Both options are not ideal for someone who wants a single product that both collects daily scraps and automatically turns them into finished compost indoors without an outdoor system. The Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon is not a composter, it only stores scraps, and the Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) is not a bin at all, it is a soil blend you add to beds. If you need hands off indoor decomposition or a large scale outdoor tumbler, this pairing is not the right choice, and you should consider a dedicated compost tumbler dual chamber or worm system instead. You can also learn how to use compost thermometer readings to monitor a true composting process.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon replace a soil amendment like Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft)?
No, they serve different stages. The Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon only collects and contains food scraps until you empty it, while the Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) is a finished organic blend you mix into raised beds to support plant growth. You would use the pail to gather material that eventually becomes compost, and the bagged mix when you need to amend soil now.
Do I need both a stainless compost bin with a lid and a bagged organic blend?
Many gardeners do use both, but you do not have to buy them together. If you already have an outdoor composting method and just need tidy indoor collection, start with the Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon. If your beds are ready to plant and need structure and moisture support, start with the Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft).
How long do odor filters last and what upkeep does each option need?
The Granrosi Compost Bin Kitchen Counter, 1.3 Gallon includes three charcoal filters, each lasting 3 to 4 months with normal use, and the stainless body needs a weekly wash with warm soapy water. The Back to the Roots 25.7qt (1 Cubic ft) needs no filter changes, just dry storage for any unused blend and normal watering after you work it into your beds.
Browse more picks in our Composting & Soil Health category, or see our related guide on Compost Thermometer Vs Worm Bin Guide.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!