If you are weighing the Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial against the Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules, you are really choosing between two completely different yard jobs. One gives your dog a consistent, designated spot to go, the other keeps rabbits and other nuisance animals away from the plants you want to protect.
This Dog Potty Grass Patch Outdoor Vs Rabbit Repellent For Garden comparison breaks down what each product actually does, how it is built, where it fits, and what upkeep it needs. You will see in 2026 which tool matches your situation, whether you need indoor convenience or outdoor protection, so you do not buy the wrong fix for your home. If you are also sorting out winter shelter for pets, you may find how to insulate outdoor dog kennel large helpful for broader yard planning.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of our links, The Yardstead may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never influence which products we recommend or how we rank them. Read our Affiliate Disclosure for details.
Quick Picks at a Glance
Prime Pomeat Cat Scat Mat 10 Pack 16×12 Inch
Prime PICKFORLIFE Artificial Grass Pad for Dogs
Prime Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules 3 lbs
Prime Bonide Go Away Rabbit, Dog & Cat Repellent
Prime Bonide Go Away! Rabbit, Dog & Cat Repellent
Prime I Must Garden Dog & Cat Repellent 3lb
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Pros
- Humane design deters pets without harming paws or skin
- Ten mats offer large coverage and can be cut and joined for custom fits
- Effective indoors and outdoors for furniture, counters and gardens
- Lightweight and easy to install, cut and reposition
- Proven to stop digging, scratching and soiling for most pets
Cons
- Persistent or very playful pets may learn to walk over the spikes
- Included U-shaped staples and small clip hooks may be too few or too short for large areas
- Requires trimming and careful placement to secure on irregular or windy outdoor surfaces
The Pomeat 10 PCS Scat Mat is a humane deterrent system designed for cat and dog owners who need to protect sofas, beds, countertops, garden beds and lawns. Each mat measures 16 by 12 inches and the ten pack is intended to be joined together for broader coverage indoors or outdoors.
In real world use, the mats are praised for working immediately to stop digging, scratching and soiling without harming animals. The tall but blunt plastic spikes discourage pets from stepping or lying down, and many users report dogs quickly learning to avoid treated posts and garden corners after one encounter.
The mats are made from lightweight, flexible plastic that can be easily cut into strips and spliced together using built in interfaces on all sides. This modular design lets you fit oval tree surrounds, narrow flower beds or couch cushions, and the included staples and cuttable curved hooks help anchor the mats in soil.
There are some limitations to consider. A few reviewers note that persistent cats and clever dogs may tolerate or walk over the spikes, reducing effectiveness. Others mention the included ground staples and small clip hooks are too short or too few to firmly secure a large layout, so extra anchoring may be needed.
Overall, this is a practical and pet safe alternative to electronic shock mats for training pets to avoid specific areas. If you need a flexible, customizable barrier for both home and garden that is gentle yet effective for most pets, this ten pack offers excellent coverage and value.
Brand: Pomeat
Model Number: LGFN34XRSE
Quantity: 10 mats
Mat Size: 16 x 12 inches each
Material: Plastic
Color: Black
Target Species: Cat and Dog
Style: Garden
Includes: Ground staples and cuttable curved hooks
Item Weight: 1.9 pounds
Pros
- Large size accommodates dogs of all sizes comfortably
- Fast drainage keeps crate and floors clean and paws dry
- Realistic 4-tone soft grass encourages dogs to use it naturally
- Very easy to clean with just a hose and mild soap
- Durable polypropylene holds up to regular washing
Cons
- Noticeable odor when first unboxed that requires airing out outdoors
- Sold as turf only, no tray or absorbent pee pads included
- Some dogs need time to adjust and may be confused at first
The PICKFORLIFE Fake Grass Pad is a large 39.3 by 31.5 inch reusable turf designed as an indoor potty solution for dogs. It is built for apartment residents, owners without easy outdoor access, and anyone potty training puppies or supporting senior or mobility limited dogs.
In real world use, the standout feature is the fast drain system with 63 holes that channels urine through quickly to keep paws and floors dry. Owners report it works especially well on rainy or cold days and on balconies, with many dogs adapting within a day or two when paired with pee pads underneath.
Build quality centers on soft, non-toxic polypropylene with four tone blades that mimic natural grass in both look and feel. The texture is gentle under paws yet durable enough for regular hosing, and the color variation makes it more realistic than flat green alternatives.
There are a few drawbacks to note. The turf arrives with a noticeable factory odor that needs outdoor airing, and it is sold as a mat only without a tray, so you will need a base or absorbent pads. Some dogs are initially confused by the surface and a few owners find the blade length a bit tall.
Overall, this is a practical, easy to clean, and pet friendly alternative to disposable pads and outdoor trips in bad weather. If you need a spacious, reusable, and low maintenance potty area that encourages natural behavior, it is a strong value choice for most homes.
Brand: PICK FOR LIFE, Model: PFL-0001A, Manufacturer Part Number: PFL-0001A, Material: Polypropylene (PP), Color: Green
Dimensions: 39.3 inches L x 31.5 inches W, Drainage: 63 holes spaced every 10 cm for rapid flow through
Care Instructions: Hand wash only, rinse with mild soap and warm water, hose clean in seconds
Best Use: Apartments, balconies, patios, bathrooms, backyards and crates, suitable for small, medium and large dogs
Pros
- Humane, non-lethal deterrent that is safe for pets and children
- Up to 60 days of protection reduces need for frequent reapplication
- Effective against a wide variety of common garden pests
- Easy ready-to-use granular format with no mixing required
- Made by Bonide, a trusted lawn and garden brand since 1926
Cons
- Effectiveness can vary by animal species and pressure
- Heavy rain or irrigation may reduce longevity and require reapplication
- Initial natural odor can be strong right after application
Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules are a ready to use 3 lb granular deterrent designed to protect lawns, gardens and planting beds from nuisance wildlife. It is built for homeowners and gardeners who need a humane solution for deer, rabbits, raccoons, squirrels, chipmunks and skunks without using traps or harmful chemicals.
Its key strength is a triple action formula that works through smell, taste and gentle irritation of the eyes and nose to encourage animals to avoid treated areas. In real world use, this creates an invisible barrier that conditions pests to stay away, and a single application can last up to 60 days in dry conditions.
Design is simple and practical, with dry granules that require no mixing, diluting or spray equipment. You just sprinkle the granules around the perimeter of gardens, flower beds and lawn edges, and the biodegradable particles blend naturally into the landscape while remaining effective.
As with most scent based repellents, results can depend on animal hunger, population pressure and weather. Heavy rain, watering or severe infestations may shorten the protection period and require earlier reapplication, and the natural odor is noticeable immediately after spreading before it fades.
Overall, Bonide Repels-All is a convenient, humane and pet friendly option for keeping common pests out of your yard and garden. For anyone seeking an easy to apply, long lasting deterrent that does not harm animals, it is a reliable and trusted choice.
Brand: Bonide
Model Number: 23614A
Form: Ready-to-Use Granules, 3 lbs
Product Dimensions: 3.75 x 7.13 x 10.75 inches, 3.1 pounds
Protection Duration: Up to 60 days per application
Target Pests: Deer, rabbits, squirrels, chipmunks, raccoons, skunks and other nuisance animals
Manufacturer: Bonide Products LLC
Pros
- Made with all natural ingredients including cinnamon oil, thyme oil and white pepper
- Safe for families and pets when applied as directed
- Versatile protection for lawns, gardens, flower beds and waste areas
- Convenient ready to use granular format
- Can help modify unwanted animal behavior over time
Cons
- Requires reapplication every two weeks or after heavy rain as scent washes away
- Mixed effectiveness reported, especially for stopping dogs from urinating on grass
- Needs a wide 4 foot band for coverage, which uses product quickly on large areas
Bonide Go Away is an outdoor granular repellent designed to deter rabbits, dogs and cats from gardens, lawns and landscaped areas. It is ideal for homeowners, gardeners and pet owners dealing with stray animals, digging or territorial marking.
Its standout feature is the all natural formula powered by cinnamon oil, thyme oil and white pepper that creates an unpleasant scent barrier for animals. Real world feedback is mixed but positive when used consistently, with many users noting success against neighborhood cats and digging pets.
The product comes as ready to use 3 lb granules that are lightly sprinkled in a 4 foot band around the area you want to protect. The dry granule format is convenient, low mess and suited for flower beds, trees, shrubs and around trash cans.
The main drawback is longevity, as heavy rain can wash away the scent and reduce effectiveness until reapplied. Some users also found it less effective for stopping dogs from urinating on grass, so results may vary by animal and habit.
Overall, Go Away is a solid natural option for humane animal deterrence and behavior training when used as directed. For best results, reapply every two weeks and combine it with other training techniques to reinforce boundaries.
Brand: Bonide, Product: Go Away Rabbit, Dog & Cat Repellent Granules, Form: Granule, Scent: Cinnamon.
Natural Active Ingredients: Cinnamon oil, thyme oil and white pepper for a high potency deterrent.
Target Species: Cats, dogs and rabbits. Recommended for lawns, gardens, flower beds, trees, shrubs and trash can areas.
Size: 3 lbs (48 ounces). Material Features: Natural formula, safe around people and pets when used as directed. Manufacturer Part Number: 871.
Pros
- Made with natural essential oils, no synthetic chemicals
- People and pet safe when used as directed
- Will not harm lawns, gardens or ornamental plants
- Convenient ready-to-use shaker container, no preparation needed
- Affordable and easy to apply over large outdoor areas
Cons
- Effectiveness is inconsistent, some animals ignore it completely
- Requires frequent reapplication, especially after rain or watering
- Strong natural scent can irritate eyes and nose during application
Bonide Go Away! Rabbit, Dog and Cat Repellent Granules is an outdoor, ready to use granular deterrent designed for homeowners, gardeners and pet owners dealing with unwanted digging, chewing and fouling. It is ideal for those who prefer a natural, non lethal way to protect lawns, flower beds, mulch and shrubs.
Its standout feature is the dual action natural formula with cinnamon oil and thyme oil that creates a scent barrier to discourage animals. In real world use, many users report success keeping rabbits and neighborhood pets out of gardens when applied as a consistent 4 foot wide band, though results vary by animal, location and habit strength.
Design is simple and practical, with a 1 pound shaker container and dispenser cap that allows for light, even distribution without mixing or special equipment. The granules are biodegradable, free from artificial fragrances, and safe around people and pets when used as directed, so you can treat areas near desirable plants with confidence.
The main drawbacks are durability and consistency. Heavy precipitation washes away the essential oils, so reapplication every two weeks is necessary for best results. The concentrated natural scent can also be strong and irritating to eyes and nose, so calm weather application is recommended, and stubborn pets may need additional training support.
Overall, Bonide Go Away! is a convenient and affordable first line defense for garden protection and behavior training. For best results, apply consistently, reapply after rain, and combine it with other positive training techniques rather than expecting a single application to solve persistent problems.
Product: Bonide Go Away! Rabbit, Dog & Cat Repellent Granules, Model 870, 1 Pound, Granule Form
Active Ingredients: Natural cinnamon oil and thyme oil, biodegradable and plant safe, thyme scent, fragrance free formula with no artificial perfumes
Use Sites: Outdoor use on lawns, gardens, flower beds, mulch, trees and shrubs, apply as a 4 foot wide band around area to protect
Application: Ready to use with dispenser cap, reapply after heavy precipitation or every two weeks, intended as a behavior modification training aid
Pros
- Natural and biodegradable formula safe for pets and plants
- Humane deterrent with no harsh chemicals
- Convenient 3lb granular size for yard and garden coverage
- Easy shaker application for targeted use
Cons
- Natural formula may require frequent reapplication after rain or watering
- Effectiveness can vary depending on animal behavior and sensitivity
- Granular scent barrier may fade faster outdoors than chemical options
The I Must Garden Dog & Cat Repellent is a 3lb granular repellent designed to protect gardens, lawns and flower beds from digging, scratching and marking. It is aimed at homeowners and gardeners who need a humane, pet friendly solution to keep dogs and cats away from landscaped areas.
Its standout feature is the natural, biodegradable formula that deters pets without harsh chemicals or harm. In real world use, the granules create a scent barrier that discourages pets from returning to treated spots, though results can vary by animal temperament and require consistent application.
Build quality is straightforward and practical, with a 3 pound shaker container that makes it easy to distribute evenly around garden perimeters. The compact packaging stores easily and the biodegradable materials break down safely into the soil without leaving residue.
As a natural repellent, it is not as immediately potent as chemical alternatives and will need reapplication after heavy rain or watering. Some pets may also be less sensitive to botanical deterrents, so training and repeated use may be needed for best results.
Overall, this is a solid choice for eco conscious gardeners seeking a safe, humane way to protect their plants. If you prioritize pet safety and natural ingredients over chemical strength, this repellent offers reliable, environmentally friendly protection.
Brand: I Must Garden
Model: DOGG48
Size: 3 Pounds Granular
Package Dimensions: 8.15 x 4.53 x 4.41 inches
Material Feature: Biodegradable
Category: Spray Repellents
Manufacturer: I Must Garden
ASIN: B0854MC68R
Best Sellers Rank: #71,120 in Pet Supplies, #140 in Dog Repellent Sprays
Head-to-Head: Grass Patch vs Granular Repellent
Purpose and Problem Solved
The Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial is designed to solve a dog owner problem. It creates a dedicated potty area for apartments, balconies, patios, bathrooms, or backyards, and helps train your pet to go in one predictable spot when bad weather, busy schedules, or limited outdoor access make walks difficult.
The Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules solves a gardener problem. It repels nuisance animals including skunks, raccoons, squirrels, chipmunks, deer and rabbits from gardens and planting areas through smell, taste, and irritation of eyes and nose. If your main frustration is chewed leaves, dug beds, or animals raiding your lawn, this is the category you need, not a potty surface.
Material, Build and How They Work
The Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial uses non-toxic polypropylene with 4-tone blades that look and feel softer and more realistic than flat all-green turf. It is built with 63 drainage holes spaced every 10 cm to maximize water flow, prevent messy buildup, and keep paws from tracking urine back onto your floor or crate.
The Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules works completely differently. It is a ready-to-use granular formula that deters animals without harming them and is listed as safe to use in pet and children’s play areas when used as directed. Instead of providing a surface, it creates an invisible sensory barrier that animals avoid, which is ideal if you want to protect flower beds, trees, shrubs, and lawn edges without installing anything.
Size, Coverage and Placement
Size tells you a lot about fit. The Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial measures 39.3 x 31.5 inches, giving small, medium, and large dogs plenty of room to move and circle before going. That footprint is made to sit flat on a balcony, patio, bathroom floor, or inside a pen, and you can hose it off in place. Learn more about versatile outdoor setups in automatic chicken feeder vs predator proof chicken run if you are planning multi-use outdoor spaces.
The Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules comes as 3 lbs of granules intended to be scattered around lawn and garden, flower beds, trees, shrubs and other planting areas. Coverage depends on how heavily you apply and how large the perimeter is, and you can target specific beds or create a border. Unlike a fixed mat, you have flexibility to treat exactly where rabbits have been feeding or digging, and you can reapply as needed around trash cans or garden edges.
Upkeep, Cleaning and Longevity
Upkeep is where these two diverge most. The Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial is designed for rapid flow-through and easy cleaning, you simply rinse it with mild soap and warm water and mess rinses off in seconds. It requires far less maintenance than natural grass, but you will need to rinse it regularly to control odor, especially with frequent indoor use, and allow it to drain fully between uses.
The Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules is biodegradable and does not require washing, but it does require reapplication. Rain, watering, and time break down the scent barrier, so you will need to refresh the granules to maintain deterrence. For low-effort garden protection you may prefer granules over physical barriers, and you can read about other low-maintenance outdoor fixes like compost tumbler dual chamber Won’t Spin? 5 fixes before you replace it to keep yard chores simple.
Which One Should You Get?
Choose the Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial if your priority is giving your dog a reliable bathroom option at home. You live in an apartment, you have a puppy in training, you want to avoid late night or bad weather walks, or you need a balcony or patio solution that feels soft under paws, drains quickly, and cleans with a quick hose down. It is the practical pick for pet convenience and house training consistency.
Choose the Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules if your priority is protecting plants and lawn from wild visitors. You see rabbit damage, deer browsing, or digging from raccoons and squirrels, and you want a people and pet safe granular deterrent for outdoor use around gardens, flower beds, and shrubs. If you are also weighing other animal control options for your property, how to use compost tumbler dual chamber shows how routine yard maintenance supports pest reduction too.
Who Should Skip Both?
Both options are not ideal for you if you need to physically block animals from entering a large enclosed area or stop persistent digging across a fence line. Neither product is a fence, net, or hard barrier, and both rely on either habit training or sensory deterrence that can fade without consistent use. If you need absolute exclusion for a vegetable garden or want to keep cats off a couch and counters without scattering granules, another option worth a look is the Pomeat 10 PCS Scat Mat for Cats Indoor 16″ x 12″ with its humane spikes, or the Bonide and I Must Garden granular repellents with cinnamon and thyme oils, but even those are not a good fit for full perimeter security.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a dog grass pad and a rabbit repellent in the same yard?
Yes, you can, but keep them separated by purpose and location. Place the Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial in a designated potty zone for your dog, and apply the Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules only around garden beds and plant perimeters you want to protect. Do not sprinkle repellent granules directly on the grass pad, as that defeats its inviting, neutral scent for training.
Will the Bonide Repels-All Granules harm my dog if he uses the grass pad nearby?
When used as directed, the Bonide Repels-All Animal Repellent Granules is described as safe to use in pet and children’s play areas and will not harm animals, it works by smell, taste, and mild eye and nose irritation. Still, you should follow label directions, keep granules off the potty pad itself, and store the bag where pets cannot chew it. If your dog is sensitive to strong scents, give extra distance between the treated garden and the potty area.
I live in an apartment, which is more useful for a balcony setup?
For an apartment balcony, the Fake Grass Pad for Dogs Potty Training Artificial is almost always more useful because it solves the everyday need for a clean, drainable potty spot without trips outside. A rabbit repellent like Bonide Repels-All is made for outdoor lawn and garden protection and has little value on a high balcony with no rabbit pressure. Choose the grass pad for city living and save granular repellents for ground-level gardens.
Browse more picks in our Dog & Pest Control category, or see our related guide on Insulate Large Dog Kennel Guide.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!